Urgency is effective.
Time-limited offers and scarcity have been selling things for decades. But there is a thin line between ethical urgency and manipulative tricks.
A couple of years ago, we conducted an experiment with one of our SaaS clients. We tried a traditional urgency tactic—countdown timers with messages such as, “Only 3 spots remaining at this price!” and “Offer ends in 2 hours!”
The outcome? A 217% rise in conversions in two weeks.
But here’s the catch—we discontinued using it.
Why? Because although it increased short-term numbers, it damaged long-term trust. And in online marketing, trust is paramount.
How Fake Urgency Works (And Why It’s So Effective)
Our brains are programmed to fear missing out. When we see:
- “Only 2 left in stock!”
- “Sale ends tonight!”
- “Join 500+ marketers before doors close!”
We feel a sense of urgency to act—even if the scarcity isn’t real.
In our test, we employed:
- Fake countdown timers (resetting for each visitor)
- Artificial stock restrictions (“Only 5 seats available” when unlimited slots were available)
- False deadline extensions (“Because of high demand, we’ve extended the deal for 24 hours!”)
It worked—too well.
The Hidden Cost of Fake Urgency
Later, after a few months, we observed:
- Higher Refund Rates – Those who were bullied into purchasing were more likely to ask for refunds.
- Negative Reviews – Some consumers caught on and called out the “scammy” approach.
- Lower Lifetime Value (LTV) – Erosion of trust equated to fewer repeat buys.
We learned that although false urgency can drive spikes in conversions, it tends to backfire over time.
What We Use Instead (Ethical Urgency That Converts)
We didn’t drop urgency completely—we just made it genuine.
Here’s what does the trick without manipulation:
1. Real Limited-Time Bonuses
Rather than artificial countdowns, we created real bonuses for early adopters (e.g., “First 50 sign-ups receive a complimentary 1:1 strategy call”).
2. Event-Based or Seasonal Promotions
Black Friday, New Year sales, or product launch discounts create inherent urgency without manipulation.
3. Honest Deadlines
If enrollment closes at midnight, it truly does—no false extensions.
4. Social Proof + Urgency Combo
Rather than “Only 3 spots remaining!”, we employed:
✅ “Join 1,200+ marketers who upgraded this week—enrollment closes Friday.”
This maintains urgency honest and ethical.
Key Takeaway: Trust > Short-Term Gains
Manipulated urgency may get the job done—but at the expense of trust.
If you’re executing email marketing for lead generation or full-service digital marketing campaigns, emphasize truthful scarcity.
Because ultimately, sustainable growth trumps quick wins every time.
Need Ethical Digital Marketing That Converts?
At 7thGrowth, we assist businesses in growing with strategic, open marketing. No gimmicks—just results.
Check out our budget-friendly digital marketing packages
Need a high-converting website? Take a look at our custom website design services
What’s your take on urgency tactics? Have you seen them backfire? Let’s discuss in the comments!
